You know what I really like? Knowing what is best for poor people. Apparently this is something one, such as me, that is a certified "white person", can like.
Several people have discovered the tongue in cheek, stuffwhitepeoplelike blog [SWPL]. The sad thing is, the first time I read through SWPL, all I could think was "wow, it's like they are following me around." Which is kinda creepy.
That and reading the blog reminds me of this old Dave Chappelle routine, where Dave considered the 'black people like fried chicken' stereotype, and how he thought he liked fried chicken because it tasted good, but as it turns out, he liked it because he is black. I feel the same way about sushi, after reading SWPL.
Admittedly, a field guide to particular cultural affectations and fetishes of the White UMC population is both informative and amusing.
Especially since the guide provides advice on how to get on a white person's good side:
"White people universally love David Sedaris. So if they ever ask you
“who are you favorite authors?” you should always reply “David
Sedaris.” They will instantly launch into a story about how much they
love his work, and the conversation will go from there, and you don’t
have to talk about books any more."
There is part of me that wants to fight the tide and stop liking David Sedaris. Although, to be honest, doing so would be akin to amputating my own toes without anesthesia.
Another part of me, upon finding SWPL, thought "that's handy." As in, wouldn't it be nice if I could just refer people to this blog to explain my multitude of interests, hang-ups and world views. Now, I have only been in like one situation where I found myself having to explain myself at the elementary level which SWPL taps-- Prior to going to law school, I had this nouveau riche boss who constantly asked me offensively intrusive questions about my tastes. He questioned the neighborhood I lived in, my political leanings, my hobbies, my interests, my taste in food, my need to listen to NPR in the office. Every fucking thing. Beyond any actual class distinctions, I think he was just a nosy little parker. So yeah, I might have sent a link to SWPL to that boss, if it had existed back then.
Most people from backgrounds other than my own do not spend time nitpicking my tastes. Actually, I have had some very cool conversations and open dialogs with people about their backgrounds. Oh wait, that's #20 for SWPL, being an expert on YOUR culture.
SWPL does provide me with a new avenue of class consciousness and awareness, however. For instance, renovation:
"All white people are born with a singular mission in life in order
to pass from regular whitehood into ultra-whitehood. Much like how
Muslims have to visit Mecca, all white people must eventually renovate
a house before they can be complete.
Of course, most white people do not reach this goal until they are
35 or older. But the need to do it is as instinctual as walking.
But it is important to note that white people have little or no
interest in renovating a suburban home built after 1960 (except in
Southern California). All white people dream about buying an older
property (”with character”) in a city, and then renovating it so the
insides look all modern with a stainless steel fridge.
Though the seed is planted from birth, it really starts to grow when
renovations take place in a family home during childhood. They don’t
understand why there are so many men with mustaches in their kitchen,
but they know that they will be gone in a few weeks leaving behind a
nicer kitchen and a happier mommy/daddy/life partner of parent.
Please note that ALL white people went through a renovation when they
were kids. This is a good subject to bond over, perhaps a story about
how you were embarassed [sic] at a sleepover when a friend went to the
bathroom and there was a contractor on the toilet. Embellish as
necessary."
Wait, you mean not everyone renovates??? You mean there are people out there who never had the pleasure of three months of refrigerator in the dining room, gaping plastic covered hole in the back of the house, father now has twenty years worth of dinner conversation monopolizing complaints? My parents renovated several times. They redid the bathrooms in the condo when I was about four. We got to pee in buckets for a week. I really enjoyed playing with Neils the contractor and his assistants. When I was 12, in preparation for my Bat Mitzvah, my parents had the entire house repainted, and my room redecorated and re-carpeted.
Now, one could argue that SWPL is in essence just another form of self-aware post-colonial cultural crit. And we should examine every entry with an eye towards determining the means that a contemporary white person uses to assert dominance in the race and class dialectics. Yes, I have a BA.
Being refreshingly post-racial however, I am free to observe the differences between races without imposing any sort of imperial agenda.
Which is why, upon reading SWPL, I did not think the blog was racist (reverse racist, I guess????), but instead thought "I wish other races had their own blogs." That's right, I want black people, Dominicans, various Asians, Poor White Trash, etc. to create their own blogs to explain in simple terms what they like. 'Cause I'm curious in that way. Tell me about the import of acrylic nail tips, certain kinds of alcohol, top forty radio stations-- I wanna know. I already understand the sublime experience that is shopping at Whole Foods (store brand soy milk). What do non-SWPL types fetishize?
Of course, if we had a website titled something like "Stuff Black People Like", even if the sight was written by a black person, someone would think it was totally racist, and not in that benign way that a sight called "Stuff White People Like" written by white people would be; but instead in that pernicious one step away from reinstating slavery racism way.
Which is why, outside of a very small niche audience, any blog attempting to convey information about any race and or culture fails.
Noticing racial differences is inherently racist as a pejorative. For instance, noticing that a lot of black people you know like a band that a lot of white people you know do not is akin to saying that black people have lower I.Q.s than white people.
Also, a didactic over-simplified discussion of race also has the fun of not knowing what to do with people who are neither black nor white, but say Chinese. Really, you have to wonder how anyone has made any progress over the past 40 years (actually 44 years).
I will finish this piece with this bit I heard on NPR's This American Life. That week's theme was "Shouting Across the Divide". Contributor Shalom Auslander permalanced for an ad agency, and had been given the task of marketing a new soft drink to the African American community. The assignment failed in that his team got caught up in figuring out whether or not black people owned bathing suits. The absurdity boggles the mind. I suspect part of the problem concerning racial disparities is that each group is caught up in the questions about the tastes of some other group. We aren't saying "we are all brothers under the skin". We're saying "wait, where do black people shop"? Or "why do white people sleep with their dogs?" And these questions are asked over and over again. And no one really has an answer--- and the person who finally provides an answer is so offended at even being asked, that everyone just retreats to their own little corner of the world. Which for white people, I guess that would be an ironically hip dive bar with a micro-brew beer.
No, seriously, SWPL has miles and miles of potential commentary. It's going to be like when my dad read David Brooks' "Bobos in Paradise."